美文网首页
Day436|政治解决方案:“贵族制”的名与实

Day436|政治解决方案:“贵族制”的名与实

作者: 綠笛 | 来源:发表于2025-10-15 11:34 被阅读0次

用大家对上段的总结贵族制来引出这段。“贵族制”对大多数人来说,这个词比较负面,代表是少数专权。作者告诉我们这个只有词而已,要看本质,而不是看外在。他用游戏中的“筹码”来解释这个词,“筹码”是代币而非真正的钱,所以“aristocracy"本质来说代表一个能把我们统治好的民主,而不是的大所以为的高高在上的、不可一事的“贵族”。

Is this aristocracy? Well, we need not be afraid of the word, if the reality is good which it betoken: words are wise men's counters, without value of their own; they are the money only of fools and politicians.
这不就是贵族制吗?是的,如果其代表的实质是好的,我们无需惧怕这个词:词语本身并无价值,不过是聪明人的筹码;只有傻子和政治家,才视之为金钱。

细节解析

1、betoken: to show (something), to be a sign of (something)预示;显示
The straight lines of his eyebrows betokened the impossibility of any sympathy.他眉毛的直线表明不可能有任何同情。《红与黑》
2、counter: a small object that is used in some board games筹码

所在段落

The Story of Philosophy《哲学的故事》第1章Plato第7节VI. The Political Solution第2段第1,2句:

Is this aristocracy? Well, we need not be afraid of the word, if the reality is good which it betoken: words are wise men's counters, without value of their own; they are the money only of fools and politicians. We want to be ruled by the best, which is what aristocracy means; have we not, Carlyle-like, yearned and prayed to be ruled by the best? But we have come to think of aristocracies as hereditary; let it be carefully noted that this Platonic aristocracy is not of that kind; one would rather call it a democratic aristocracy. For the people , instead of blindly electing the lesser of two evils presented to them as candidates by nominating cliques, will here be themselves, every one them, the candidates; and will receive an equal chance of educational election to public office. There is no caste here; no inheritance of position or privilege; no stoppage of talent impecuniously born; the son of a ruler begins on the same level, and receives the same treatment and opportunity, as the son of a bootblack; if the ruler's son is a dolt he falls at the first shearing; if the bootblack's son is a man of ability the way is clear for him to become a guardian of the state(423). Career will be open to talent wherever it is born. This is a democracy of the schools — a hundredfold more honest and more effective than a democracy of the polls.
浙江大学译本: 这是不是贵族政体呢?如果它确实代表的是美好,那么我们无须惧怕这个词:词语是聪明人的游戏筹码,本身并不具备任何价值;只有傻子和政治家才把它们当成真正的金钱。

上句见:Day435

相关文章

  • 公务员低薪制带来的贵族政治

    在秦汉以前,中国是标准的贵族政治时代,但自从始皇帝建立郡县制以来,中国就逐渐走向了平民政治,从隋朝开科举以后,贵族...

  • 为什么汉代要实行,分封制和郡县制并存的制度?

    当分封制所代表的贵族政治被证明随着血缘关系的淡化,贵族会为了权力向君王发出挑战时,秦始皇将目光朝向了以官僚政治为核...

  • 橙色漫游之五:平安,藤原。

    第二阶段:藤原氏摄关家与摄关政治,以及律令制的有名无实。 进入摄关之前,还得先说说“律令制”。 究竟什么是律令制?...

  • 王莽变法

    商鞅变法后,实行军爵制,贵族世袭制被打破,经过700多年,形成新的既得利益集团:世族。 世族与贵族不同,没有得到政...

  • 名与实

    昨天,多伦多猛龙队成了NBA总冠军,华裔球员林书豪获得了一枚NBA总冠军的戒指。 总冠军戒指是许多...

  • 名与实

    这种花我最近才认识,它的名字很吓人,叫“水鬼蕉”。听名字,应该不算“正面人物”,但实际上却不是这样的。它别...

  • 名与实

    读过三国演义的人应该都知道袁术,他是袁绍同父异母的亲弟弟。 这个人,张口就是吾家四世三公云云。这个人,只注重“名”...

  • 名与实

    这几年,生态建设已经成了的大家的口头禅。 做个项目、修个房子啥的,要是不与生态挂上边,好像做项...

  • 名与实

    子路(对孔子)说:“卫国国君要您去治理国家,您打算先从哪些事情做起呢?”孔子说:“那一定是纠正混乱的名称。”子路说...

  • 《社会契约论》于当代贵族政治一瞥

    民主与贵族 按照卢梭的分法,如果行政官比单纯的公民多则为民主制;反之,若行政官比单纯的公民少则为贵族制。从这一点来...

网友评论

      本文标题:Day436|政治解决方案:“贵族制”的名与实

      本文链接:https://www.haomeiwen.com/subject/looitstx.html