美文网首页
Day450|政治解决方案:柏拉图VS康德

Day450|政治解决方案:柏拉图VS康德

作者: 綠笛 | 来源:发表于2025-11-12 08:03 被阅读0次

康德据称是守时守到令人发指的地步,只为看卢梭的《爱弥尔》破过例。当然只是据称,说是他朋友的特点移植到他身上,毕竟这样更有戏剧性。
就哲学与生活的联系度上,柏拉图远胜康德,前者与具体现实生活交融,后者则有点闭门造车之嫌。两者只是从两方面来研究哲学,应无好坏之分。

By philosophy Plato means an active culture, wisdom that mixes with the concrete busyness of life; he does not mean a closeted and impractical metaphysician; Plato "is the man who least resemble Kant, which is (with all respect) a considerable merit."17
17Faguet, P.10.
柏拉图所说的“哲学”,指的是一种富有生命力的文化形态——是与生活中具体而切实的忙碌尝试交融的智慧;他所指的绝非那种闭门索居、脱离现实的形而上学。正如法盖(Faguet)所言,柏拉图是“最不像康德之人,而这一点(恕我直言)正是他一大过人之处。17”
17:参见法盖(Faguet),第10页

细节解析

1、busyness: the state of being or appearing to be actively engaged in an activity忙碌
Busyness has become a badge of honor.忙碌已成为一种荣誉的象征。《马特的极简生活》
2、closeted: shut up in, or as in, a closet; kept in a closet; secret; hidden; private, retired秘密的;
我们熟悉的“skeleton in the /your closet”及“in/out of the closet”,前者表示“家丑”,后者表示“出不出柜”。都是偏秘密、偏隐私,有点不见得关。

3、with all respect /with the greatest respect: used for showing that you are about to disagree with someone or criticize them in a polite way恕我直言
Her examiner talked so much, with all respect.

所在段落

The Story of Philosophy《哲学的故事》第1章Plato第7节VI. The Political Solution第4段第6句:

But how can men of fifty have a flexible intelligence? Will they not be mentally plaster-casted by routine? Adeimantus (echoing, no doubt, some hot brotherly debate in Plato's home) objects that philosophers are dolts or rogues, who would rule either foolishly, or selfishly, or both. "The votaries of philosophy who carry on the study not only in youth with a view to education, but as the pursuit of their maturer years — these men for the most part grow into very strange beings, not to say utter scoundrels; and the result with those who may be considered the best of them is, that they are made useless to the world by the very study which you extol" (487). This is a fair enough description of some bespectacled modern philosophers; but Plato answers that he has guarded against this difficulty by giving his philosophers the training of life as well as the audition of the schools; that they will in consequence be men of action rather than merely men of thought — men seasoned to high purposes and noble temper by long experience and trial. By philosophy Plato means an active culture, wisdom that mixes with the concrete busyness of life; he does not mean a closeted and impractical metaphysician; Plato "is the man who least resemble Kant, which is (with all respect) a considerable merit."17
17Faguet, P.10.

浙江大学译本: 柏拉图口中的哲学是一种充满活力、与生活息息相关的文化和智慧:他口中的哲学家不是整日躲在家中、不切实际的形而上学论者;柏拉图便是“与康德最不相似之人,而这一点(谦逊地说)也正是他一个极大的优点”①。

上句见:Day449

相关文章

  • 《 理想国》笔记

    一、柏拉图的政治理想与政治实践 柏拉图经历了雅典与斯巴达之间漫长的伯罗奔尼撒战争,雅典的政治动荡让他对现实政治失望...

  • [译]约翰·多兰《康德 vs 叔本华》

    康德 vs 叔本华 【美】约翰·多兰 陈子弘 译 为了争论的缘故他把世界区分成叔本华和康德。他说他是康德,而我...

  • 你眼中的哲学是这样子吗

    关于哲学,上学时有接触过柏拉图的政治哲学,皮罗主义的不可知论,文艺复兴时期关于人的局限的哲学反思,康德的判断力批判...

  • 道法术器

    道 老子: 道 易经: 不易 佛陀:觉悟 涅槃 耶稣:上帝 柏拉图:理型 康德:物自体 荣格:自性 ...

  • 《理想国》读后感(上)

    《理想国》读后感------柏拉图 柏拉图《书札》第七卷:“推崇真正的哲学,是哲学家获得政权,成为政治家,或者政治...

  • 赴一场教育之约DAY2:用有限创造无限

    说起哲学,我们脑海中可能会浮现孔子、马克思、柏拉图、泰勒斯、苏格拉底、柏拉图、亚里士多德、康德、尼采等等许多人,虽...

  • 读《法律篇》第一卷

    《法律篇》是柏拉图晚年的著作,也是他的对话录里最厚的一本。柏拉图关于政治、法律的对话主要包括《理想国》《政治家》和...

  • 第九讲

    柏拉图(3):政治编织与法律 传统上,柏拉图政治哲学最重要的作品是三部作品。这三部作品,在今天的熟悉程度是非常不一...

  • 简单的康德

    康德是德国古典哲学的奠基人物,被认为是继苏格拉底、柏拉图和亚里士多德之后,西方最具影响力的思想家之一。康德用“三大...

  • Unity:VS没有Unity的智能提示

    环境:Unity2019.4+VS2019问题:VS打开C#脚本不会智能提示Unity的成员 解决方案: 安装VS...

网友评论

      本文标题:Day450|政治解决方案:柏拉图VS康德

      本文链接:https://www.haomeiwen.com/subject/pboyfstx.html